How does stuff like this make it into professional journals?

Any publication with the title of A Novel Treatment Approach to Over-Pronation Dysfunction is going to get my attention, mostly because of the nonsensical understanding of “overpronation”. I was not disappointed and it was as bad as I expected.

Even before I got the full paper, just reading bits like this in the preview: “The literature supports a forefoot varus as the most frequent cause of over-pronation compensation. 1,2“. The two cited references did not show that and one was him quoting himself saying that. The alarm bells start going off about a lack of academic rigour and lack of critical thinking skills. A true forefoot varus (based on the textbook definition) is actually quite rare and far from being a common casue of “overpronation”.

On reviewing the full paper, the author proposes a new treatment for forefoot varus (which he has a patent on), when they don’t even know what forefoot varus really is! The author is confusing the theoretical constructs of ‘forefoot varus’ and ‘forefoot supinatus’ and really has no clue how foot orthotics even work in those two different constructs. There is certainly a lack of critical thinking skills and academic rigour in what is being written by the author (not to mentioned the editorial and peer review processes that allowed it to be published). I have written many times before (eg) about this confusion between the two and the chicken and egg situation with research that is done on one or the other or both.

I went onto great detail on the difference between the theoretical constructs of forefoot varus and forefoot supinatus here. Both present as an inverted forefoot when the lateral column is loaded and the rearfoot about neutral. Basically, the construct of forefoot varus is that it is osseous, rare, not correctable and is a cause of “overpronation”; whereas the construct of forefoot supinatus is that it is a soft tissue contracture, common, is correctable, but is the result of “overpronation”.

A simple cursory read of the paper shows that the author had no idea about forefoot supinatus (and does not even mention it) and ascribes some of the characteristics of forefoot supinatus to confuse it with what he thinks is a forefoot varus (its not). As a forefoot supinatus is a soft tissue contracture, then what he proposes can be helpful, is not new and is not novel and has been like a number of strategies that have been used for a forefoot supinatus over the years. The nature of what he is proposing will facilitate the stretching out of the soft tissue contracture as have mobilisation techniques been doing that for years. So too has the nature of the short foot exercise been restoring the “arch height” of those with a forefoot supinatus. However, all those techniques, including the one proposed by the author, will fail in a forefoot varus as it is a bony or osseous issue.

The problem with a forefoot supinatus is something is causing it. This is not acknowledged by the author, let alone understood by him. The approach advocated by the author is destined to fail in the long term unless that cause is removed. Short terms gains in arch height could be expected with what he is proposing.

The author then justifies his approach by applying the “it worked for me” logical fallacy. Seriously? In a professional journal?

At least the journal did include a response by Robert D. Phillips, DPM to what was published. My only criticism of what Daryl wrote is that he was too polite and should have ridiculed the concept.

I do acknowledge that there can be a difference of professional opinions, but in this case, this is not a case of professional opinion, but a confused superfical misunderstanding of the literature and a misunderstanding and misuse of concepts and terminology. It certainly lacks the academic rigour to be published in a professional journal.

On one hand, I am perplexed how something as confused as this can make it through the editorial and peer review process of a professional journal. On the other hand, we are talking about JAPMA who regularly publishes papers that are below an acceptable standard (see my posts here and here) and for some reason, republished the paper that was previously published in another journal (Journal of Orthopaedic Physical Therapy Practice) that from what I can tell does not even exist as a journal. There is a magazine by that name, but not a journal!

Please sign up for my newsletter when a new content is posted:




Advertisement:

SaleBestseller No. 1
Brightech LightView Pro 6 Wheel Rolling Base Magnifying Floor Lamp - Magnifier with Bright LED Light for Facials, Lash Extensions - Standing Mag Lamp for Sewing, Cross Stitch, Crafts
  • BIG, BRIGHT & DIMMABLE MAGNIFYING LIGHT TO SEE SMALL DETAILS EASILY: This magnifier lamp was designed to ease your close up focus, even with vision problems such as aging eyes or macular degeneration. This lamp includes a built in dimmer switch so you get exactly the right light. The 3" wide, diopter glass magnifying lens will magnify whatever you are working on up to 175%. The LED lights don't get hot so you can enjoy your hobbies comfortably.
  • COMFORT & EASE OF USE FOR PROFESSIONALS: HANDSFREE USE & SMOOTH ROLL EVEN ON BAD SURFACES: Free both hands to work thanks to the flexible arms and pivoting head get the light and lens right where you want it; the powerful springs then keep it in place. The 6 wheels roll easily, making it perfect for spas and salons, estheticians, dermatologists, beauticians, jewelers, tattoo artists, dentists etc. Facials lash extensions and other treatments are a cinch.
  • REVIEWS: GREAT FOR READING, SEWING, KNITTING, QUILTING, PUZZLES, CROCHET, CROSS STITCH etc: Reviewers say this light helps them enjoy hobbies by reducing eye strain and avoiding headaches. Plus they feel greater pride and achievement in as a result of more precise detail work. Beside those mentioned, soldering, painting (e.g. minis), woodworking, drawing, repair of small electronics and fly trying are other common uses.
  • REAL DIOPTER GLASS MAGNIFIES 1.75X & 20 YEAR LIFE LED LIGHTS FOR MAX DURABILITY - AVOID REPLACEMENT HASSLES - The genuine diopter glass means the lens doesn't warp with time or heat, and is also scratch resistant. So it lasts longer than cheap acrylic/plastic lenses. This model features 1.75X magnification with things in focus at a distance of 13 inches. The 9W & 800 lumen LED lights are built in and last 20,000 hours - about 20 years if you use the Brightech Lightview Pro 3 hours every day!
  • BRIGHTECH'S 3 YEAR PRODUCT WARRANTY: We proudly stand behind all of our products 100%, which is why we offer a full 3 year warranty. If your lamp has any defect or stops working within 3 years, we help you troubleshoot and/or send replacement parts or a whole new product. If any problems arise, please contact us because our number one goal is customer satisfaction.
SaleBestseller No. 2
McGlamry's Comprehensive Textbook of Foot and Ankle Surgery, Volume 1 and Volume 2
  • Used Book in Good Condition
  • Hardcover Book
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 2112 Pages - 11/17/2012 (Publication Date) - LWW (Publisher)
Bestseller No. 3
CYTING Foot Doctor Keychain The Human Foot is A Masterpiece of Engineering and A Work of Art Podiatry Keychain Graduation Gift for Podiatrist Appreciation Gift (Podiatrist Keychain)
  • 👣"The human foot is a masterpiece of engineering and a work of art" Podiatry keychain - Whether you're a Podiatrist, Podiatrist student or grad, or looking for a gift for one, this podiatrist keychain is a perfect keepsake!
  • 👣Are you looking for a fantastic gift that a Podiatrist will remember forever due to its uniqueness and thoughtfulness? Do you want an amazing looking gift dedicated to Podiatrists that will make their eyes light up as soon as they see it? A gift to a podiatrist and original gift for a surgeon.
  • 👣The podiatrist keychain is packed in a velvet bag ready for giving. This foot doctor keychain would be perfect for a podiatrist or for someone who works in a podiatrist office.
  • 👣Material👣: Stainless Steel and alloy, they are lead free and nickel free. Stainless steel is hypo allergenic, it doesn’t rust, change colour or tarnish.
  • 👣Measure👣: bar pendant: 5cm (1.97") * 1.2cm (0.47"), key ring diameter: 3cm (1.18"). A great design for yourself or your favorite Podiatrist!
SaleBestseller No. 4
The Podiatry Practice Business Solution: Everything You Need to Know to Flourish in Your Podiatry Business
  • Hardcover Book
  • Wishnie, Peter (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 174 Pages - 02/28/2020 (Publication Date) - Stonebrook Pub. (Publisher)
SaleBestseller No. 5
Mann’s Surgery of the Foot and Ankle, 2-Volume Set: Expert Consult: Online and Print (Coughlin, Surgery of the Foot and Ankle 2v Set)
  • Mosby
  • Hardcover Book
  • Saltzman MD, Charles L. (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 2336 Pages - 11/06/2013 (Publication Date) - Mosby (Publisher)
Bestseller No. 6
Podiatry Axial/Sesamoid Weight Bearing Sponge (Closed Cell)
  • Closed Cell - 13" x 8" x 4"
  • Closed Cell Sponges are made from a lightweight, radiolucent, non-porous foam. The perfect solution for any positioning need. These positioning sponges are entirely fluid resistant, easy to clean and extremely durable! Featured in a non-coated, premium charcoal grey color.
  • Closed cell sponges are 100% Radiolucent for artifact free imaging. Cleanable, fluid resistant surface. Lightweight and comfortable. Closed cell is the number one option in positioning sponges.
  • Stealth Sponges are designed with proprietary "flared" angles to offer significantly reduced artifacts during viewing. Flared sides will increase overall size. Non-Stealth Sponges are formed with traditional angles and do not feature our proprietary "flared" angles to offer significantly reduced artifacts during viewing. Non-stealth (or non-flared) sides may show artifacts when imaging, specifically when coating is applied.
  • Returns of this item can be made within ten (10) business days from delivery and are subject to a 25% restocking fee. All genuine Techno-Aide products are guaranteed for one year from the initial date of purchase for defects in material and workmanship. Proudly made in the USA and sold by a Veteran Owned Small Business.
SaleBestseller No. 7
Watkins' Manual of Foot and Ankle Medicine and Surgery
  • LWW
  • Watkins, Leon (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 732 Pages - 12/21/2016 (Publication Date) - LWW (Publisher)
SaleBestseller No. 8
Foot and Ankle Radiology
  • Hardcover Book
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 624 Pages - 12/31/2014 (Publication Date) - LWW (Publisher)
SaleBestseller No. 9
Operative Techniques in Foot and Ankle Surgery
  • Hardcover Book
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 1394 Pages - 10/19/2016 (Publication Date) - LWW (Publisher)
SaleBestseller No. 10
Professional Double Ended Nail Curette 1.5/2.5mm Dermal Ingrown Toenail Cleaner Scoop Chiropody Podiatry Tools
  • Manufactured from High Quality Medical Grade Stainless Steel
  • Nail Cleaning and Care Instruments
  • One End Has 1.5mm Scoop While the Other Has 2.5mm Cup
  • Dual-Use Tool is For Trimming Cuticles, Cleaning Fingernails and Giving Manicures Pedicure
  • Removes Non-living Tissue Around the Cuticles, Cleaning Under the Nails and Along Side Walls

I get commissions for purchases made through links on this website. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases

1 thought on “How does stuff like this make it into professional journals?

  1. Avatarjonathan palmer

    I have been an MSK Podiatrist for 25 years , and worked for HM Royal Marines for 20 years . I’ve looked, moved and reduced (In casting process) supinatus almost daily and almost never use a forefoot varus posting which is strictly against my religion….. wait for it… Unless there is a true forefoot varus and the remaining mechanical picture so requires it.

    True bony varus is indeed rare as evidenced by my daily examinations and castings over this long period.

    Anyone who might try to advise you otherwise ought to be treated with total scepticism. Fake news !11

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *